Experiments for the Chorus of Angels Tablecloth

Comparison of cloak stitching, petal stitch on one side, triangular up and down buttonhole stitch on the other.

With sixteen angels to do, it seemed like a good idea to work out a plan of action. My first idea was to have green capes with red stitching and red capes with green stitching, so that was the first thing I tried. Red on green is certainly working, and looking at the comparison between petal stitch or an upward pointing stitch for the trim on the cape, it seemed to me that petal stitch was the clear winner, so I put that in place.

Comparison again: somehow it is clearer that the dress should not have red trim

Yes, definitely, that works.

And I like closed feather for the trim around the shoulders, too.

The red neckline and hem – not so much. It looks like a failed attempt to link the trim on the cape, rather than a harmonious trim on a dress. Ugh!

Part of the problem, I think, is that the border is too narrow, but I was afraid of the red pulling itself forward too much.

Skirt trimmed now in a palish green, and the edges of the cape are in place

So, here’s what I’ve settled on.

The cape is edged with Mountmellick stitch, which makes a rather charming edging stitch. I think of it as a cross between blanket stitch and chain stitch, even though it’s not really, and wasn’t used as such originally. The dress edging is much broader than the first one, two rows of up-&-down blanket stitch face to face, and you will note that I’ve patterned them, with a V-shape alternating with a short pair of stitches. Then I’ve added two rows of cable chain stitch to broaden the edging further.

6 Comments

  1. Sue Jones says:

    Ah, yes, the second version is much more coherent, and reads better as a dress separate to the cloak.
    The spiky stitches on the dress echo the pine-needle pattern on the green fabric very nicely.

  2. Lin says:

    As always, nice to see your trials and errors!

  3. The Petal Stitch is just right!

  4. Alex Hall says:

    The green is much more successful, I think, as is the petal stitch which feels softer and less spiky. Looking forward to seeing how these develop!

  5. Linda says:

    It will be interesting to see how this progresses.

  6. Carolyn Foley says:

    It is always useful to ‘audition’ stitches. Saves a lot of unpicking.